🦇 Party Game

Gay Halloween Would You Rather

Two bad options, one October, no way out. Pick one, defend it to the room, and find out who you were really friends with.

2–12 players
10–30 min
30 cards

Gay HalloweenWould You Rather

SPOOKY

How to Play

1Read the card out loudBoth options, start to finish. "Both" and "neither" are not answers.
2Everyone picksPoint, shout or say it on three. Choose before you have time to be sensible.
3Defend your choiceThirty seconds to justify yourself. The worse the option, the better the case.
4Majority rulesWhoever ends up in the smaller camp takes the sip — or takes the mockery.

About This Game

What's in the Deck

30 cards
One card type, endlessly reshuffled
Shuffled fresh every round
One phone, whole group

Good For

Halloween pre-drinks
Costume parties
Couples who like arguing
Horror movie nights

Sample Cards

A few off the top of the deck. The rest you find out the hard way.

Would you rather be haunted by a very polite ghost or a deeply judgemental one?

Would you rather survive one night in Scream or one night in Hocus Pocus?

Would you rather be the sexy cat every year or the group’s designated photographer?

Would you rather get read by Elvira or by a Drag Race judge?

Would you rather date a vampire who’s a top or a werewolf who texts back?